Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy)

By Scott G. Schreiber

Proposing the 1st book-length research in English of Aristotle s Sophistical Refutations, this paintings takes a clean examine this seminal textual content on fake reasoning. via a cautious and important research of Aristotle s examples of sophistical reasoning, Scott G. Schreiber explores Aristotle s reason for his taxonomy of twelve fallacy kinds. opposite to sure glossy makes an attempt to lessen all unsuitable reasoning to both mistakes of logical shape or linguistic imprecision, Aristotle insists that, as vital as shape and language are, particular types of fake reasoning derive their persuasiveness from wrong ideals concerning the nature of language and the character of the world."

Show description

Preview of Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy) PDF

Similar Ancient Greece books

The Oresteia: Agamemnon; The Libation Bearers; The Eumenides

Within the Oresteia Aeschylus addressed the bloody chain of homicide and revenge in the royal relatives of Argos. As they flow from darkness to mild, from rage to self-governance, from primitive ritual to civilized establishment, their spirit of fight and regeneration turns into an enduring music of occasion.

Socrates: A Man for Our Times

“Spectacular . . . A pride to learn. ”—The Wall road Journal From bestselling biographer and historian Paul Johnson, a super portrait of Socrates, the founder of philosophyIn his hugely acclaimed sort, historian Paul Johnson masterfully disentangles centuries of scarce assets to supply a riveting account of Socrates, who's usually hailed because the most vital philosopher of all time.

Eros and Greek Athletics

Historic Greek athletics supply us a transparent window on many vital features of old tradition, a few of that have particular parallels with glossy activities and their position in our society. historical athletics have been heavily attached with faith, the formation of younger women and men of their gender roles, and the development of sexuality.

The Great Sophists in Periclean Athens

The arriving of the Sophists in Athens in the midst of the 5th century B. C. was once a massive highbrow occasion, for they introduced with them a brand new approach to educating based on rhetoric and impressive doctrines which broke clear of culture. during this ebook de Romilly investigates the explanations for the preliminary good fortune of the Sophists and the response opposed to them, within the context of the tradition and civilization of classical Athens.

Extra info for Aristotle on False Reasoning: Language and the World in the Sophistical Refutations (Suny Series in Ancient Greek Philosophy)

Show sample text content

If the item stated is known in lots of methods . . . and one is aware every now and then the way it is fake and from time to time the way it is right, one needs to point out that it's acknowledged in lots of methods and that during a technique it truly is fake and in a different way it really is precise. For if one may still make the excellence later, it truly is uncertain no matter if he additionally understood the amphibolous query firstly. 35 there's no cause to appreciate amphibolous questions as deviating from the feel of “amphiboly” constantly maintained. Dialectical questions usually are not unmarried phrases. 36 In Rhetoric III, five, 1407a32, 38, Aristotle is illustrating five ideas of excellent Greek diction (™rc‹ t›V l°xewV t¿ …llhn√zein—1407a19–20). The 3rd precept isn't to take advantage of amphibolies: this can be so until one intends the opposite [i. e. , intends to be ambiguous], as these do once they don't have anything to assert yet fake to assert anything. those type of humans say these items in verse, like Empedocles. For [verse] which matches on for a very long time in circles tips the listeners and they're affected simply because the many are who take heed to the seers. For once they [the seers] say amphibolous issues, they [the listeners] convey their assent—“Croesus, through crossing the Halys, will smash an excellent realm. ”37 Homonymy and Amphiboly 31 this example of prophetic amphiboly continues to be a inventory instance in undemanding good judgment texts. it really is tougher to situate into Aristotle’s type of amphiboly, simply because neither morphology nor syntax appear to create a context of ambiguity. My advice is that the Croesus prophecy illustrates the “power of names” brought in S. E. 1 because it applies to a complete proposition. ponder back Aristotle’s examples of misreasoning as a result of homonymy. those integrated circumstances not just of phrases signifying other kinds of items (manqºnein, tΩ d°onta) but in addition phrases signifying a similar type of factor in a different way qualified (e. g. , Socrates ill now, and Socrates ailing before). The latter examples are extra illustrative of the S. E. 1 strength of names than of the slender experience of homonymy defined in different types 1. So too within the Croesus prophecy, this amphiboly exemplifies the facility of universal phrases, whilst joined in a normal predication, to suggest a number of situations of that normal predication. based on Herodotus (I, ninety one) the anomaly within the oracle was once which nice realm (that of Cyrus or that of Croesus himself ) will be destroyed. there isn't any ambiguous syntax the following. it is a case the place the prophecy makes a basic declare that could characterize multiple specific occasion. Aristotle says of instances just like the Croesus prophecy that seers, so that it will decrease their possibilities of being fallacious, “speak in the course of the genera of the actual fact. ”38 Aristotle subsequent illustrates this dating among the very fact (t¿ prøg ma) and its genus (t¿ g °noV) via the connection (1) among a selected quantity (p¬sa) and the atypical or the even numbers, and (2) among a selected destiny time (t¿ p¬te) and the long run regularly. 39 What we now have right here, then, is a recurrence of that vast S. E. 1 energy of names to indicate many stuff, this time showing within the context of amphiboly.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.16 of 5 – based on 45 votes