Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said's Orientalism

By Ibn Warraq

This is often the 1st systematic critique of Edward Said's influential paintings, Orientalism, a ebook that for nearly 3 a long time has acquired large acclaim, voluminous remark, and translation into greater than fifteen languages. Said’s major thesis was once that the Western picture of the East was once seriously biased by way of colonialist attitudes, racism, and greater than centuries of political exploitation. even if Said’s critique used to be arguable, the impression of his principles has been a pervasive rethinking of Western perceptions of japanese cultures, plus a bent to view all scholarship in Oriental reports as tainted by means of concerns of strength and prejudice.

In this thorough reconsideration of Said’s recognized paintings, Ibn Warraq argues that Said’s case opposed to the West is heavily mistaken. Warraq accuses stated of not just willfully misinterpreting the paintings of many students, but in addition of systematically misrepresenting Western civilization as an entire. With instance after instance, he indicates that ever because the Greeks Western civilization has consistently had a strand in its very make-up that has approved non-Westerners with open palms and has ever been open to overseas rules.

The writer additionally criticizes acknowledged for insufficient technique, incoherent arguments, and a defective ancient knowing. He issues out, not just Said’s tendentious interpretations, yet ancient howlers that might make a sophomore blush.

Warraq additional seems on the damaging impact of Said's research at the historical past of Western portray, particularly of the nineteenth century, and indicates how, once more, the epigones of acknowledged have succeeded in relegating millions of top quality work to the lofts and garage rooms of significant museums.

An prolonged appendix reconsiders the price of 18th- and 19th-century Orientalist students and artists, whose paintings fell into disrepute because of Said’s paintings.

Show description

Preview of Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said's Orientalism PDF

Best Cultural Studies books

Agnosticism: A Very Short Introduction

What's agnosticism? Is it a trust, or in simple terms the absence of trust? Is it the results of too little thought of an issue--or an excessive amount of? Who have been the 1st to name themselves "agnostics"? Does agnosticism deserve severe attention this present day? Can an agnostic stay a spiritual lifestyles? What position may still agnosticism have in schooling?

A Brief History of Ancient Greece: Politics, Society, and Culture

Written by way of 5 major specialists at the classical international, a short historical past of historical Greece: Politics, Society, and tradition, 3rd variation, is a shorter model of the authors' hugely winning historic Greece: A Political, Social, and Cultural background, 3rd variation (OUP, 2011). It deals a charming account of Greek civilization and historical past in all its complexity and diversity, masking the complete interval from the Bronze Age during the Hellenistic period.

Sherlock Holmes and Conan Doyle: Multi-Media Afterlives

Sherlock Holmes is an iconic determine inside of cultural narratives. extra lately, Conan Doyle has additionally seemed as a fictional determine in modern novels and movies, complicated the limits among fiction and truth. This assortment investigates how Holmes and Doyle have gripped the general public mind's eye to develop into vital figures of modernity.

Cultural Amnesia: Notes in the Margin of My Time

'One stupendous starburst of untamed brilliance' SIMON SCHAMA 'Aphoristic and acutely provocative: a crash direction in civilization' J. M. COETZEE prepared from A via Z, and containing over a hundred essays, Cultural Amnesia is the last word advisor to the 20th century. 'This is a gorgeous booklet.

Extra resources for Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said's Orientalism

Show sample text content

Inspired through his visits to Cluniac abbeys and priories in Spain in 1141 and 1142, Peter deliberate an formidable undertaking to translate Arabic texts into Latin. He set approximately deciding on his translators, and one of many first works to be translated was once Al-Kindi's Risala. Peter picked translators, Robert of Ketton and Herman of Dalmatia, the latter translating the Masa 'il Abi-al-Harith `Abdallah ibn Salam and the Kitab Nasab al-Rusul through stated ibn Umar, and the previous the Koran and a suite of Judeo-Islamic legends. Peter himself produced a refutation of Islamic doctrine utilizing reason-out of affection, it was once said-and now not out of hatred. 12 Robert of Ketton had already been translating clinical works from the Arabic in Spain and is understood for his Latin translation, Liber algebrae et Almu- cabola, of al-Khwarizmi's guide of algebra, al-Kitab al-mukhtasarfi hisab aljabr wa-al-muqabalah. the interpretation of the Koran was once totally one other topic, yet he set approximately it in a committed demeanour. Robert accomplished his translation of the Koran in 1143, and was once good paid for his pains. Then he went again to his clinical translations. His used to be the 1st entire translation of the Koran in a Western language and have become a medieval most sensible vendor. " Its accuracy has been attacked ever considering that. Juan (or John) of Segovia objected to what he considered as the cavalier manner Robert had translated and to his department of the Koran into greater than the traditional 114 suras. fifty four Futhermore, Robert "had moved what used to be initially of many Koranic passages to the tip, and vice-versa; he had altered the which means of Koranic phrases as he translated them; he had usually disregarded what was once explicitly within the textual content, yet included into his Latin model what used to be merely implicit within the Arabic unique. "55 Ludovico Marracci likewise came across Robert's attempt extra of a paraphrase than a devoted translation. ,, within the eighteenth century, George Sale wrote within the preface to his personal translation, "[T]he booklet merits no longer the identify of a translation; the unaccountable liberties therein taken and the numberless faults, either one of omission and fee, leaving scarce any resemblance of the unique. "„ although, Thomas Burman, in a chain of lucid and convincing articles, convention papers, and books,58 has argued that Robert's rendering is important of recognize in its personal correct and positively stands compared to, for instance, the extra literal translation of Mark of Toledo. Burman contends that Robert's ver Sion frequently displays properly the Muslim figuring out in their personal holy booklet, extra so than Mark of Toledo's literal attempt. Burman additional exhibits that Mark used to be additionally obliged occasionally to show to Arabic exegetical literature to make experience of that opaque textual content. fifty nine it really is attention-grabbing to notice that Robert rearranged the order of the passages in order that what used to be first and foremost of many Koranic passages he moved to the tip, and vice versa. this can be an analogous uncomplicated precept hired through Richard Bell, approximately 8 hundred years later, in his recognized translation of the Koran that got here out among 1937 and 1939.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.51 of 5 – based on 4 votes