Rethinking "Gnosticism": An Argument for Dismantling a Dubious Category

Most a person attracted to such subject matters as production mythology, Jungian concept, or the assumption of "secret teachings" in historical Judaism and Christianity has chanced on "gnosticism" compelling. but the time period "gnosticism," which regularly connotes a unmarried rebellious flow opposed to the present religions of overdue antiquity, offers the misunderstanding of a monolithic non secular phenomenon. the following Michael Williams demanding situations the validity of the generally invoked classification of historical "gnosticism" and the methods it's been defined. proposing such recognized writings and activities because the Apocryphon of John and Valentinian Christianity, Williams uncovers the similarities and modifications between a few significant traditions largely categorised as gnostic. He offers an eloquent, systematic argument for a extra actual approach to speak about those interpretive approaches.

The smooth build "gnosticism" isn't really justified through any old self-definition, and lots of of the main usually stated spiritual positive aspects that supposedly outline gnosticism phenomenologically grow to be questionable. Exploring the pattern units of "gnostic" teachings, Williams refutes generalizations referring to asceticism and libertinism, attitudes towards the physique and the created international, and alleged beneficial properties of protest, parasitism, and elitism. He sketches a clean version for figuring out historical options on extra "mainstream" Judaism and Christianity, a version that's trained via glossy study on dynamics in new spiritual events and is free of the fake stereotypes from which the class "gnosticism" has been constructed.

Show description

Preview of Rethinking "Gnosticism": An Argument for Dismantling a Dubious Category PDF

Similar Christianity books

The Jesus Family Tomb: The Discovery, the Investigation, and the Evidence That Could Change History

The Jesus relations Tomb tells the tale of what could be the best archaeological locate of all time—the discovery of the relatives tomb of Jesus of Nazareth. Following the unintentional bulldozing of a tomb through the development of a housing advanced in suburban Jerusalem in 1980, archaeologists from the Israeli Antiquities Authority have been instantly referred to as to the scene.

A People's History of Christianity: The Other Side of the Story

The Grassroots activities That Preserved Jesus's Message of Social Justice for 2,000 Years and Their influence at the Church TodayFor too lengthy, the heritage of Christianity has been informed because the triumph of orthodox doctrine imposed via energy. Now, historian Diana Butler Bass sheds new mild at the staggering ways in which many Christians have refused to comply to a inflexible church hierarchy and sought to recapture the unconventional implications of Jesus's lifestyles and message.

The Triumph of Christianity: How the Jesus Movement Became the World's Largest Religion

Celebrated non secular and social historian Rodney Starktraces the extreme upward push of Christianity via its so much pivotal andcontroversial moments to supply clean viewpoint at the heritage of the world’slargest faith. within the Triumph of Christianity, the writer of God’sBattalions and the increase of Christianity gathers and refines decadesof robust learn and discovery into one centred, concise, and highlyreadable quantity that explores Christianity’s most vital episodes.

Martin Luther: A Life (Penguin Lives)

Known as ? the main influential interpreter of yank faith? by way of invoice Moyers, popular historian and Lutheran pastor Martin Marty portrays the non secular reformer Martin Luther as a guy of moral sense and braveness who risked loss of life to ignite the ancient reformation of the Church. Luther? s arguments, together with his ?

Additional info for Rethinking "Gnosticism": An Argument for Dismantling a Dubious Category

Show sample text content

Brox’s argument is extra convincing so far as the time period “gnosis” is anxious, considering Irenaeus does use the word “knowledge falsely so referred to as” to explain the final physique of heresy that's the objective of his five-volume paintings. sixteen nonetheless, Irenaeus’s use of the time period gnostikos, “gnostic,” provides a unique case. in this time period, a view thoroughly opposite to that of Brox is taken by means of Adelin Rousseau and Louis Doutreleau, the editors of the assets Chrétiennes version of Irenaeus’s Adversus haereses. They argue that Irenaeus makes use of gnostikos in senses: (1) with the term’s “basic and common that means” of “learned” (savant), and (2) just about adherents of the specific sect known as “the gnostic heresy” in Adv. haer. 1. eleven. 1. in keeping with Rousseau and Doutreleau, except for 3 situations of the first feel in e-book 1, together with the connection with the self-designation via the fans of Marcellina in 1. 25. 6, all the different passages i've got mentioned are examples of the second one utilization, denoting a specific sect. 17 Now what I desire to indicate is that whichever of those critiques is towards the reality, Irenaeus may nonetheless not often be a witness to a selfdefinitional utilization of gnostikos that justifies the fashionable class “gnosticism. ” If Irenaeus does primarily restrict the designation “gnostics” to a specific sect, as Rousseau and Doutreleau contend, then his testimony a minimum of deals no aid for the trendy inclusion of alternative teams similar to the Valentinians below the rubric “gnosticism” at the foundation of self-designation. nevertheless, if Brox is true, Irenaeus’s personal utilization of the time period gnostikos easily as a common synonym for “heretic” will be even much less cause to set up a different classification at the foundation of the meant use of this time period as a self-designation. HIPPOLYTUS within the early 3rd century C. E. , Hippolytus of Rome composed one other catalog of sects, during which he used to be partially depending on Irenaeus’s Adversus haereses. 18 The first component of Hippolytus’s Refutatio omnium haeresium (“Refutation of the entire Sects”) surveys quite a few traditions from Greek philosophy and historical astrology and magic. Books five via nine hide the sects or “heresies” as indexed in desk 1, and ebook 10 is a recapitulation. And so far as terminology is anxious, there's little or no correlation among Hippolytus’s use of the time period gnostikos and the fashionable class. on the subject of purely teams does Hippolytus say that they known as themselves gnostikoi. 19 The first is a gaggle whom Hippolytus himself prefers to 38 C H A P T E R T W O name the “Naassenes,” or “serpentists” (from their emphasis on Naas, the “serpent”). yet even if Hippolytus says that they name themselves gnostikoi (Ref. five. 2, five. 6. four, five. eight. 29, five. eleven. 1), he additionally rates them as educating that out of all humanity they're “the basically precise Christians” (Ref. five. nine. 22). 20 this means that the designation gnostikoi refers to a high quality that they as Christians valued (openness to wisdom) instead of to a spiritual identification assorted from being Christian21—perhaps within the means one glossy Christian may perhaps wish to classify herself as a (Christian) “intellectual,” whereas one other may possibly name himself a “born-again” (Christian).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.25 of 5 – based on 22 votes